diff --git a/Userland/Shell/Builtin.cpp b/Userland/Shell/Builtin.cpp
index c6a5d0dbbb..78a525ae8f 100644
--- a/Userland/Shell/Builtin.cpp
+++ b/Userland/Shell/Builtin.cpp
@@ -218,11 +218,6 @@ ErrorOr<int> Shell::builtin_unalias(Main::Arguments arguments)
 
 ErrorOr<int> Shell::builtin_break(Main::Arguments arguments)
 {
-    if (!m_in_posix_mode) {
-        raise_error(ShellError::EvaluatedSyntaxError, "break: Invalid use of builtin break in non-POSIX mode");
-        return 1;
-    }
-
     unsigned count = 1;
 
     Core::ArgsParser parser;
@@ -243,11 +238,6 @@ ErrorOr<int> Shell::builtin_break(Main::Arguments arguments)
 
 ErrorOr<int> Shell::builtin_continue(Main::Arguments arguments)
 {
-    if (!m_in_posix_mode) {
-        raise_error(ShellError::EvaluatedSyntaxError, "break: Invalid use of builtin continue in non-POSIX mode");
-        return 1;
-    }
-
     unsigned count = 1;
 
     Core::ArgsParser parser;
@@ -1337,7 +1327,7 @@ ErrorOr<bool> Shell::run_builtin(const AST::Command& command, Vector<NonnullRefP
     if (name == ":"sv)
         name = "noop"sv;
 
-#define __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(builtin)                               \
+#define __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(builtin, _mode)                        \
     if (name == #builtin) {                                              \
         retval = TRY(builtin_##builtin(arguments_object));               \
         if (!has_error(ShellError::None))                                \
@@ -1787,11 +1777,6 @@ ErrorOr<int> Shell::builtin_argsparser_parse(Main::Arguments arguments)
 
 ErrorOr<int> Shell::builtin_read(Main::Arguments arguments)
 {
-    if (!m_in_posix_mode) {
-        raise_error(ShellError::EvaluatedSyntaxError, "read: POSIX builtin used in non-POSIX mode");
-        return 1;
-    }
-
     bool no_escape = false;
     Vector<DeprecatedString> variables;
 
@@ -1937,9 +1922,11 @@ bool Shell::has_builtin(StringView name) const
     if (name == ":"sv)
         return true;
 
-#define __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(builtin) \
-    if (name == #builtin) {                \
-        return true;                       \
+#define __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(builtin, mode)                            \
+    if (name == #builtin) {                                                 \
+        if (POSIXModeRequirement::mode == POSIXModeRequirement::InAllModes) \
+            return true;                                                    \
+        return m_in_posix_mode;                                             \
     }
 
     ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTINS();
diff --git a/Userland/Shell/Shell.h b/Userland/Shell/Shell.h
index 2db09617b3..d705f90bea 100644
--- a/Userland/Shell/Shell.h
+++ b/Userland/Shell/Shell.h
@@ -23,42 +23,42 @@
 #include <LibMain/Main.h>
 #include <termios.h>
 
-#define ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTINS()          \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(alias)        \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(where)        \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(cd)           \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(cdh)          \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(pwd)          \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(type)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(exec)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(exit)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(export)       \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(glob)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(unalias)      \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(unset)        \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(history)      \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(umask)        \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(not )         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(dirs)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(pushd)        \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(popd)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(setopt)       \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(shift)        \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(source)       \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(time)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(jobs)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(disown)       \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(fg)           \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(bg)           \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(wait)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(dump)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(kill)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(noop)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(break)        \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(continue)     \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(read)         \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(run_with_env) \
-    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(argsparser_parse)
+#define ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTINS()                           \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(alias, InAllModes)             \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(where, InAllModes)             \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(cd, InAllModes)                \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(cdh, InAllModes)               \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(pwd, InAllModes)               \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(type, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(exec, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(exit, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(export, InAllModes)            \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(glob, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(unalias, InAllModes)           \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(unset, InAllModes)             \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(history, InAllModes)           \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(umask, InAllModes)             \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(not, InAllModes)               \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(dirs, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(pushd, InAllModes)             \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(popd, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(setopt, InAllModes)            \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(shift, InAllModes)             \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(source, InAllModes)            \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(time, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(jobs, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(disown, InAllModes)            \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(fg, InAllModes)                \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(bg, InAllModes)                \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(wait, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(dump, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(kill, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(noop, InAllModes)              \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(break, OnlyInPOSIXMode)        \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(continue, OnlyInPOSIXMode)     \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(read, OnlyInPOSIXMode)         \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(run_with_env, OnlyInPOSIXMode) \
+    __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(argsparser_parse, InAllModes)
 
 #define ENUMERATE_SHELL_OPTIONS()                                                                                    \
     __ENUMERATE_SHELL_OPTION(inline_exec_keep_empty_segments, false, "Keep empty segments in inline execute $(...)") \
@@ -91,6 +91,11 @@ namespace Shell {
 
 class Shell;
 
+enum class POSIXModeRequirement {
+    OnlyInPOSIXMode,
+    InAllModes,
+};
+
 class Shell : public Core::Object {
     C_OBJECT(Shell);
 
@@ -443,7 +448,7 @@ private:
 
     ErrorOr<RefPtr<AST::Node>> immediate_length_impl(AST::ImmediateExpression& invoking_node, Vector<NonnullRefPtr<AST::Node>> const&, bool across);
 
-#define __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(builtin) \
+#define __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(builtin, _mode) \
     ErrorOr<int> builtin_##builtin(Main::Arguments);
 
     ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTINS();
@@ -451,7 +456,7 @@ private:
 #undef __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN
 
     static constexpr Array builtin_names = {
-#define __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(builtin) #builtin##sv,
+#define __ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTIN(builtin, _mode) #builtin##sv,
 
         ENUMERATE_SHELL_BUILTINS()